R (TJ Trading Express Ltd) v SSHD [2026] EWCA Civ 1368
The Court of Appeal has confirmed that the Home Office can revoke a sponsor licence immediately, without warning and without hearing from the sponsor first, where a mandatory ground is clearly breached. An honest mistake is not a defence.
What happened
A petrol station’s director, who was also its Level 1 SMS user, assigned a Certificate of Sponsorship to his brother-in-law.
The Home Office revoked the licence immediately. One reason was that the CoS had been assigned to a relative. The other was that it doubted the job was genuine.
The High Court quashed the revocation, but the Court of Appeal reinstated it.
Why it matters to you
Assigning a CoS to a relative of an SMS user is a mandatory ground for revocation (Annex C1(o)). The relatives covered include in-laws, partners, siblings, parents and children.
There is no right to explain before the licence is revoked. The court said this breach does not imply dishonesty, so the Home Office does not have to hear from you first.
Not knowing the rules is not mitigation. The court found that a misunderstanding caused by not reading the guidance does not count.
A legal challenge is difficult. If the Home Office says each ground is enough on its own, winning on one ground may not save the licence.
Revocation means:
sponsored workers’ permission is curtailed;
you cannot apply for a new licence for 12 months;
in the care sector, CQC, the DHSC and local authorities are told.
What you should do now
Audit every CoS you have assigned. Check whether any worker is related to, or the partner of, your Authorising Officer, Key Contact or any SMS user.
Tell us straight away if you find a family connection. Do not try to correct it on the SMS before taking advice.
Introduce a check before any CoS is assigned. The person assigning it should confirm in writing that the worker is not related to anyone with SMS access.
Train all SMS users on the sponsor guidance, especially the mandatory grounds in Annex C1.
Keep evidence that each vacancy is genuine: the job description, advertising, recruitment records and a business case for the role.
Review who has SMS access. Remove anyone who no longer needs it.
How we can help
We offer:
sponsor compliance audits;
SMS user training;
mock compliance visits;
urgent advice on suspension, downgrade or revocation.
Please contact Rumbidzai Bvunzawabaya to arrange a review. Book a consultation here: https://calendly.com/info-56205/business-immigration-consultation?month=2026-11
This briefing is general information and is not legal advice on your circumstances.