“Robbed, Anxious, Cheated”: What we Heard at our Earned Settlement Community Session

On Monday 16 November, Tulia held an online community planning session on earned settlement Watch Recording Here. People joined from across the UK: skilled workers, professionals, graduates, people on the long residence route, and others affected. We asked how they felt about the announcement. The most common answer was “robbed”. Next came “anxious”, “cheated” and “unfair”.

How people are feeling

Many described feeling trapped, mentally drained and hopeless. When asked about job security and stability, most who answered said they feel much less secure. Several said they haven’t slept properly since the announcement on 2 November.

What people told us

  • They planned their lives around the five-year route. Many are only months from applying for settlement. As one person put it: “We planned our lives around the 5 year route and it must be respected.”

  • The costs are heavy. People described thousands of pounds already spent on visas, the Immigration Health Surcharge and family extensions, and said they cannot start again.

  • Being tied to one employer is a major worry. Some said employers are refusing letters, threatening to withdraw sponsorship, or that progression has stalled. Several asked for visas that are not tied to a single employer.

  • The earnings threshold feels unfair. Many who shared their pay were earning between about £25,000 and £35,000, well below £50,271. People asked how pay can be the measure of contribution when pay scales and regional salaries differ.

  • Families and children are affected. Parents raised university costs, dependants’ routes and the strain on relationships.

  • Some feel left out. People on the long residence route, and those in roles that have been removed or reclassified, said no one is speaking for them.

“We have already paid financially and mentally for this settlement. What do they want us to do more to belong to this society?”

“We came legally. We should be treated fairly. They should consider us HUMANS.”

Questions people still need answered

Many were unsure about English language requirements, how dependants and partners are treated, how the £25,000 care worker threshold works, what happens to removed occupation codes, and how long routes will be for children. We will use these questions to shape our guidance and our evidence gathering.

What people are asking for

  • Transitional protection for everyone already in the UK

  • No retrospective changes to the five-year route

  • Visas that are not tied to a single employer

  • A review of the May 2025 cut-off date

  • Clear, published guidance on the new rules

If this affects your wellbeing

If you are struggling, please talk to someone. You can contact Mind or call Samaritans free on 116 123, any time.

What happens next

We are reading every contribution. These views will shape our research and campaign, including a survey and focus groups, and what we take to the Home Office and other decision-makers. We are also working to bring organisations together so we can speak with a stronger voice.

What you can do now

  1. Email your MP. Find them at WriteToThem. Say who you are, how the changes affect you, without identifying details, and ask for transitional protection for people already here.

  2. Join the actions led by other organisations. Participants shared the Skilled Migrants Alliance, the Parliament petition “Protect the five-year ILR route for existing Skilled Workers”, and other groups.

  3. Join our WhatsApp group if you want to take part in our campaign and research: WhatsApp link

This session was a community and research session, not legal advice. Quotes are anonymised and lightly edited for spelling. Chat and poll responses are informal and do not represent everyone affected.

Previous
Previous

Paid for a UK Job that did not Exist? This is an Important Development.

Next
Next

What the Diaspora Can Learn from the Five-Year ILR Victory